Method
How information is sourced, dated and checked on Productive Levant: primary sources first, a clear line between what is established and what is not, a verification date and a real status for every programme.
Every programme sheet and every piece on Productive Levant follows the same rules. They are set out here so that readers can judge each figure for themselves.
The programme before the announcement
A pledge or a signed agreement does not yet help any firm. The site covers what a firm can apply for: the window, the channel, the documents, the money.
An announcement gets a programme sheet once there is something to apply for. Until then, it is treated as an announcement and labelled as such.
Primary sources first
Each figure is traced, wherever possible, to the document it comes from: the programme’s rules, the call for applications, the financing agreement, the official gazette, an institution’s annual report or dataset.
Press articles and secondary reports are leads. They point to a source; they do not replace it.
Sources are listed at the foot of each sheet, with a link when the document is public.
What is established, and what is not
Some useful information has no traceable origin: a figure repeated from report to report, a condition applicants mention but no text contains. It can still be published, provided its status is clear.
Each statement belongs to one of three categories:
- Established: backed by a primary source, which is cited.
- Reported: from a partial or secondary source – an applicant, a bank officer, a press report – and attributed as such.
- Unconfirmed: origin not found, or impossible to check. The text says so, in those words.
A figure whose origin cannot be found is neither dropped silently nor presented as fact. It is published with that limit stated, or not at all.
The verification date
Each sheet shows the date it was last checked against its sources. That date is information in itself: terms change, windows close, money runs out.
What the reader sees depends on the age of the last check:
| Last check | What the reader sees |
|---|---|
| Less than 3 months ago | A ‘Verified’ badge with the date. |
| 3 to 6 months ago | The date, without the badge. The sheet is queued for a new check. |
| 6 to 12 months ago | A banner saying the sheet is due for a new check. |
| More than 12 months ago | A notice at the top of the page. The sheet is treated as an archive until it is checked again. |
A new check changes the date, even when nothing else changes. Every change to a sheet is logged in its history, with its date.
Real status
Every programme carries one of five statuses. It describes what a firm can do today, not what was announced.
| Status | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Open | Applications are accepted now, through a working channel, and money is available. |
| Closed | The window has ended or the money is used up. No new applications are accepted. |
| Suspended | Applications or payments are on hold, officially or in practice, with no confirmed restart date. |
| Funded but not open | Money has been committed, by a donor or in a budget, but no application window has opened yet. |
| Ghost programme | Announced or still listed, but no working window can be found: no channel to apply, no recent payment, no office able to process an application. Used only after documented checks. |
A status changes only on the basis of a dated source or a documented check. A programme is labelled a ghost only after checks with official channels, the institution in charge and applicants. The sheet describes those checks.
Money: local currency, then US dollars
Amounts are given in the programme’s currency, usually the local one, followed by a US dollar equivalent.
The equivalent states the exchange rate used and its date. Where several rates coexist, the sheet names the one applied.
Announced envelopes and disbursed amounts are never added together or confused. When only the announced figure is known, the sheet says so.
Worked examples
Each sheet and each analysis includes a worked example in figures: what the programme means for one firm, in money and in time.
The example is either real – a firm’s case, used with its consent and without its name – or modelled from the programme’s published terms. A modelled example is labelled as such, with its assumptions.
Same programme, five countries
Comparisons set one type of support side by side across Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, Palestine and Iraq, in a standard table: country, programme, ceiling, rate, eligibility, lead time, real status.
Each comparison ends by naming the most and the least favourable terms, and why. When a country has no equivalent, the table says so: a gap is a finding too.
Photographs
Photographs are credited and dated. Captions say what the picture shows and where.
File metadata, such as location data, is removed before publication. When no suitable photograph exists, a typographic image showing the piece’s key figure is used instead.
Experience reports
Accounts from firms are read and checked for consistency before publication, and anonymised by default. How to send one: share your experience.
Errors and updates
Corrections are dated and visible at the foot of the page, as set out in the corrections policy. A wrong figure or a programme that has changed can be flagged on report an error.
What the site publishes, and refuses to publish, is set out in the editorial rules.